Do I Need Comprehensive Insurance?

Fran Majidi
February 12, 2019

What is comprehensive insurance, other than the strange cousin of collision insurance? Clearly, collision insurance covers a car wreck of some sort, but what’s the real definition of comprehensive insurance when the word “comprehensive” cannot possibly mean that it covers everything (and it doesn’t)? In this article we will aim to clarify what comprehensive auto insurance actually covers while differentiating it from collision auto insurance, another very important coverage that is often bought together in a bundle with comprehensive coverage. Remember that both collision and comprehensive coverages are optional, unless your financial institution requires full coverage.

What Does Comprehensive Car Insurance Cover?

Comprehensive auto insurance is not required. It is an optional coverage designed to protect you against damage that is not defined as a collision with another car or object. The following are some events in which your car will be covered if you have comprehensive car insurance:

  • Fire
  • Theft
  • Vandalism
  • Falling object
  • Hitting wildlife
  • Natural disasters (hail, flood)

In some states, comprehensive car insurance covers glass replacement without a deductible payment. How wonderful (and rare) is that? Usually, there is a deductible you must pay in order for your coverage to begin. Deductibles range from $100 to $1,000. The lower your deductible, the higher your monthly premiums and vice versa. Let’s say your deductible was $500 and the damage to your car will cost $2500 to fix. You’d pay the $500 and your car insurance company will pay $2000.

Even though comprehensive insurance is different from collision insurance, often you must buy collision in order to buy comprehensive. Both are required by lienholders when you finance or lease a vehicle. The reason why lienholders require it is that the institution you borrowed from technically owns the car and wants to protect their asset while you’re making payments on it. Even if you own your car and aren’t required to have it, comprehensive auto insurance is an important coverage to consider.

The rate for your comprehensive coverage will depend on several variables, one of them being its susceptibility to theft. Did you know that Hondas Civics are stolen more than any other car? It would naturally follow that despite its economical price-tag, Honda Civics are a little bit expensive to insure.

Other factors that raise comprehensive car insurance rate:

  • Hazardous conditions (lots of wildlife crossing in the area)
  • Insecure car parking (street parking in a city will probably yield a very high rate)

What Does Fully Comprehensive Insurance Mean?

Fully comprehensive insurance is just another way of saying comprehensive insurance or comprehensive car insurance. All of these terms are misnomers for a product that is not comprehensive in the least. If you get into a car crash and it was your fault, comprehensive will not cover you. This is why in many states you need to have comprehensive to buy collision (in case you hit that deer and called it a collision, because in a way it is one.). In fact, most insurance companies will not allow you to buy collision coverage without comprehensive coverage. But many policies offer comprehensive without collision. Totally confused? It’s okay. Just buy both unless the total of the two is more than 10% of the total blue-book value of your car.

Does Comprehensive Auto Insurance Cover Everything?

No, not everything is covered under comprehensive coverage. The following are instances comprehensive insurance does not cover:

  • Collision
  • Roadside assistance (towing)
  • Tire change
  • Gas, oil and water delivery
  • Battery services
  • Lockout services
  • Rental reimbursement
  • Personal property
  • Rollovers

Comprehensive vs Collision Insurance

By now, you’re wondering, “What Is the difference between comprehensive and collision insurance?” There’s a reason why these two very distinct coverages are thought of as one unit or are often paired together. Chances are that you are simply interested in getting compensated for your valuable, regardless of whether you hit a deer, an air conditioner fell on your roof or your car was carried away in a sudden flood. When the damage to your car was not a direct result of a car accident chances are you would need comprehensive to be covered for it. If you know cars in your neighborhood get stolen, as expensive as comprehensive insurance will be, it’s better than losing all the money you dumped into a stolen car (and the payments you’ll still be responsible for).

Comprehensive insurance is three to four times cheaper than collision. For both types of coverage, there is a deductible (separate for each one) and the total claim amount will never exceed the market value of the vehicle the day the claim was filed.

Is Comprehensive Insurance Required Where I Live?

No, comprehensive insurance isn’t required by law in any state. This doesn’t mean that your financing company, or lienholder, won’t require you to have it if you’re financing or leasing a car from them.

What Else Should I Know About Comprehensive Auto Insurance?

If you have the latest safety features on your car, especially anti-theft protection, make sure to tell your insurance agent who may be able to get you a discount. The less vulnerable your car is to theft, the lower your comprehensive car insurance rate will be.

I Have an Old Car. Do I Still Need Collision and Comprehensive Insurance?

It never makes sense to overpay. Keeping in mind that you will never get paid out more than the market value of the car, your optional auto insurance costs (this is not counting liability) should never exceed 10% of what the insurance company would pay you out. So, find out what your car’s worth today on Kelly Black book. Take 10% of that and compare it to your payments.

What Else Should I Know?

Never pay too much for car insurance. Compare rates with us today to see if we can knock a couple of hundred dollars off your current rate. Visit us here.

Get a Free Auto Insurance Quote Online Now.

Related Articles

Auto Insurance AARP Hartford Auto Insurance Review

AARP began in 1958 as a nonprofit membership organization for 50+ individuals. The AARP Hartford Auto Insurance Program has been around since 1984.

Auto Insurance Insurance Comparison Sites: What You Need to Know

Several new insurance comparison sites promise to compare all the available policies to pinpoint the one that’s perfect for you. Which is best?

Looking for Auto Insurance?

Compare rates from dozens of companies in less than 3 minutes.