Average Car Insurance Costs in New Jersey

How much is insurance in the Garden State?

Fran Majidi July 1, 2024
average auto insurance rates in new jersey

With a population of over 8.9 million, New Jersey is the 11th most populated state in the country and features over 85,000 miles of road. There are many factors that go into calculating the rate you pay for car insurance. Below is a breakdown of how much drivers in New Jersey pay for coverage based on different factors. To learn more about insurance requirements in New Jersey, check out New Jersey Car Insurance.

New Jersey Car Insurance Rates by Age

Typically car insurance companies will charge more for younger drivers and provide discounted rates for older drivers. Insurance carriers see young drivers as inexperienced and have a greater risk of getting in accident. In New Jersey, the typical teen driver between the age of 16 and 19 will pay $233.50 per month while a driver in their 40s will pay an average of $186.18 per month.

AgeAvg monthly rate
20s $233.50
Over 80 $146.38
60s $169.21
50s $186.18
70s $153.65
30s $188.39
40s $192.57
16 - 20 $327.15

New Jersey Car Insurance Rates by Marital Status


Married couples in New Jersey typically pay more for their car insurance than drivers who are single. This likely due to the simple fact that there is more than 1 driver on the policy. Married couples also will usually have more than one vehicle and could possibly have some teen drivers on the policy as well. In New Jersey, Married couple typically pay around $192.05 per month while single drivers average in around $223.80 per month.

Marital StatusAvg monthly rate
Single $196.70
Married $192.05
Divorced $223.80
Widowed $220.07
Separated $239.30

Average Car Insurance Rates in New Jersey by Credit Score

Many factors go into the rate you pay for car insurance. Your age, location, and vehicle are all part of the equation. Insurance companies also take your credit score into consideration. In New Jersey, drivers with excellent credit pay an average of $195.55 per month compared to drivers with poor credit who typically will pay $303.97 per month.

Credit RatingAvg monthly rate
Good $195.55
Excellent $157.24
Poor $303.97

Car Insurance for High Risk Drivers in New Jersey

Drivers with a good driving history typically will pay less for auto insurance than someone that had a DUI, speeding tickets, or an accident. Car insurance companies see drivers with a bad driving history has being a bigger risk. Drivers in New Jersey with a good driving history usually pay around $256.78 per month. Drivers with a bad driving history that may include tickets, DUI, or accidents will typically pay $188.35 per month.

Safe Driver (No prior tickets, DUI, or accidents)Avg monthly rate
Safe Drivers $188.35
High Risk Drivers $256.78

New Jersey Auto Insurance Rates by Homeownership

Insurance companies will also take homeownership into account when factoring the rate you pay for insurance. In New Jersey, drivers who own their home will usually pay around $199.69 per month while drivers who rent usually average in around $183.83.

HomeownershipAvg monthly rate
Rent $199.69
Own $183.83

Currently Insured vs. Uninsured in New Jersey


More often than not, drivers who currently have car insurance coverage will receive a cheaper monthly rate than drivers who do not. Since car insurance is a requirement in all 50 states, companies may question why you don't currently have coverage. Because of this, they may see you as a higher risk driver. In New Jersey, the average monthly rate for a driver who is currently insured is $205.00 while drivers who not currently covered will pay around $191.64

CoverageAvg monthly rate
Currently Insured $191.64
Not Currently Insured $205.00

New Jersey Car Insurance by Education

Car insurance companies will also look at your education level. Although not usually a significant factor, your education can effect your monthly rate for auto insurance. In New Jersey, a driver with a High School Diploma will typically pay $237.32 per month vs. someone with a Bachelors Degree who will be charged around $217.22 per month.

EducationAvg monthly rate
Associate Degree $179.77
Bachelors Degree $195.51
Masters Degree $187.76
High School Diploma $237.32
Some College $217.22
Less than High School $198.08
Doctorate Degree $165.19

Liability vs. Full Coverage Car Insurance in New Jersey

Liability only coverage is typically cheaper and covers the cost of damage you may cause to other people or vehicles. Full coverage includes comprehensive and collision insurance, possibly PIP and UM/UMPD, which would cover you, your vehicle and passengers if you had an accident, regardless of fault. In (State) the average rate for liability only coverage is around $176.89 per month compared to Full coverage which will cost you about $196.82 per month.

CoverageAvg monthly rate
Full Coverage $196.82
Liability Only $176.89

The statistics listed on this page are from our own in house reporting. We track and record quotes that carriers have provided based on various criteria. The rates and averages shown on this page should only be used as an estimate.

compare insurance

Compare Car Insurance Rates in New Jersey for Free

Answer a few questions and let Penny find the best rates in your area.