How Much Is New York Car Insurance?

Ever wonder how much drivers in New York pay for car insurance? Check out the average price that most people pay and see if you can find a cheaper rate.

Get Quotes in Less Than 3 Minutes

Affordable Car Insurance in New York

As one of the world’s major cultural, financial and commercial centers, New York City is an awe-inspiring place full of iconic sites and attractions. As a whole, New York state’s popularity means a higher cost of living, but that certainly doesn’t mean you can’t find affordable auto insurance there.

New York insurance rates vary widely depending on which Empire State zip code you live in, but all residents can benefit from our unbiased, carrier-neutral information on rates and features. We provide options that allow you to choose the coverage that’s right for your specific needs and budget.

Cheapest Auto Insurance Rates in New York

Carriers look at multiple variables when determining your insurance rate. Your age, location, driving history, and state requirements are all factors in determining the price you pay. We used our in-house reporting to determine the companies that offer the cheapest car insurance rates in New York. New York Central Mutual Fire came in with the lowest rate currently available in New York at $124.16 per month. Followed by Erie at $144.26 per month and USAA at $146.83 per month.

Lowest Rate

New York Central Mutual Fire

Highest Rate

Central Mutual Insurance Co

Average Rate

New York

RankCompanyAvg monthly rate
1 New York Central Mutual Fire $124.16 / month
2 Erie $144.26 / month
3 USAA $146.83 / month
4 Travelers $178.39 / month
5 State Farm $193.77 / month
6 Nationwide $206.97 / month
7 Allstate $225.23 / month
8 Hanover $259.23 / month
9 Encompass $319.53 / month
10 Preferred Mutual $336.20 / month
11 Esurance $382.87 / month
12 Central Mutual Insurance Co $395.49 / month

Top 10 Cheapest Cities for Car Insurance

If you are lucky enough to live in one of these cities you are likely paying some of the lowest car insurance rates available in New York. According to our data, Lyons comes in at the cheapest at only $83.35 per month. Other cities that made the top 10 list include Painted Post at $84.47 per month, Waterford at $89.09 per month, and Vestal at $89.34 per month.

RankCityAvg monthly rate
1 Lyons, NY$83.35 / month
2 Painted Post, NY$84.47 / month
3 Waterford, NY$89.09 / month
4 Vestal, NY$89.34 / month
5 Olean, NY$89.65 / month
6 Waverly, NY$89.95 / month
7 Elmira, NY$90.27 / month
8 Newark, NY$91.62 / month
9 Corning, NY$91.86 / month
10 Geneva, NY$92.09 / month

Top 10 Most Expensive Cities for Car Insurance

These top 10 cities ranked as the most expensive places in New York for car insurance. Location is a big factor when determining the price you pay for car insurance and these cities came in at the top. South Ozone Park is the most expensive city in New York at $332.92 per month. Second and third place goes to Floral Park at $328.56 per month and Brooklyn at $314.87 per month.

RankCityAvg monthly rate
1 South Ozone Park , NY $332.92 / month
2 Floral Park , NY $328.56 / month
3 Brooklyn , NY $314.87 / month
4 Springfield Gardens , NY $303.21 / month
5 Howard Beach , NY $301.41 / month
6 Saint Albans , NY $289.81 / month
7 Arverne , NY $288.23 / month
8 Bayside , NY $288.17 / month
9 Bronx , NY $286.81 / month
10 Lindenhurst , NY $286.37 / month

Average Quotes by Top Companies

Rates can vary wildly from company to company. Here is a quick look at a few rates from some of the top car insurance companies in New York.

Compare Recent Car Insurance Quotes in New York

SmartFinancial helps thousands of drivers every day find and compare the best car insurance rates available. Here is a list of some recent quotes that we recently found for drivers in New York.

CompanyMonthly rateVehicle
Dairyland $832014 Nissan Altima
Liberty Mutual $502016 Toyota Rav4
Foremost Auto $722020 Ford Mustang
ClearCover $1152021 Chevrolet Equinox
Safe Auto $602012 Dodge Grand Caravan
Liberty Mutual $902024 Nissan Sentra
Mercury $1352024 Tesla Model Y
General $1442013 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited
Metlife $1092021 Chevrolet Traverse
Dairyland $1622007 Honda Civic
Metlife $732012 Toyota 4RUNNER
21st Century $512016 Subaru Impreza


The statistics listed on this page are from our own in house reporting. We track and record quotes that carriers have provided based on various criteria. The rates and averages shown on this page should only be used as an estimate.

Minimum Car Insurance Coverage in New York

Every state requires drivers to have a minimum amount of liability coverage. New York drivers are required to carry liability insurance to pay for damages and injuries inflicted on someone else in an auto accident.


Bodily injury coverage per person

Minimum coverage for serious or permanent injury to a single person


Death liability coverage per person

Minimum coverage for death for a person involved in an accident


Property damage liability per accident

The minimum payment for damaged property in an accident caused by you

In New York, you must have state-issued auto liability insurance coverage to register your vehicle. If you fail to continuously maintain this coverage, the Department of Motor Vehicles can suspend your driver's license and registration.

The minimum amount of coverage is $10,000 for property damage, $25,000 for bodily injury and $50,000 for the accidental death of one person. For two or more people involved in an accident, you must carry $50,000 for bodily injury and $100,000 for death. New York also requires a minimum of $25,000 of uninsured motorist coverage.

New York is a no-fault insurance state, and drivers are required to carry personal injury protection in the minimum amount of $50,000. This insurance provides motorists with benefits toward medical and rehabilitation costs, death-related expenses, lost wages, and more.

Most lenders require a level of insurance much greater than that required by law. Some may also request that you add a variety of optional coverages to your policy. Always check with potential lenders before purchasing a new vehicle, and clear policy changes with your finance company to prevent penalties.

Optional Coverage in New York

  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Auto Loan/Lease (or "gap")
  • Rental Car and Travel Expenses
  • Emergency Roadside Service
  • Mechanical Breakdown
  • Medical Payments
  • Additional Uninsured Motorist

Electing to buy optional coverages from the possibilities below provides extra peace of mind and financial protection. Some exclusions will apply.

New York Car Safety

Distracted driving, heavy congestion, a high number of tourists, and other factors contribute to New York's high number of vehicle crashes and associated injuries each year. Plus, 5% of drivers in New York are uninsured and many more are underinsured, which means there's a decent chance your next accident could be with someone who's not properly covered.

There are a few telling state safety stats below. Visit New York State's page about Distracted Driving, Talking & Texting for more information on the dangers of distracted driving.

Car Safety for New York Kids

New York law states that all children under the age of 4 years must ride in a child safety seat. Children have to ride in a child restraint system until they turn 8 years old. All child restraint systems and safety seats must be certified according to Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 213 and meet the weight and size requirements for the child based on manufacturer recommendations and federal requirements.

An appropriate child safety restraint system can be a safety seat, harness, vest, or booster seat. These should not be used in the front seat of your vehicle.

Infant seats are generally for babies weighing 22 pounds or less and who are 25 inches or less in length. These seats should be rear-facing.

Infants and toddlers weighing 40 pounds or less qualify for convertible child safety seats. Follow the manufacturer's instructions as to when these seats should be repositioned from rear-facing to front-facing.

Children who have outgrown toddler and convertible seats should be placed in a certified booster seat for children ages 4 to 8 years and weighing 40 to 80 pounds. Once your child reaches 4 feet, 9 inches, he or she is tall enough to use an adult seat belt in most vehicles.

Children 12 years of age and younger should ride in the back seat whenever possible due to safety concerns over injuries related to the deployment of airbags. Children under the age of 16 must wear a seat belt whether they are in the front or back seat.

New York may be a northern state, but that doesn't mean the temperatures don't pose a threat to children left in vehicles. Even when outside temperatures are only 70 degrees Fahrenheit, the inside of a car parked in the sun can increase 30 degrees within 30 minutes. These temperatures can quickly lead to brain damage or death. Never leave a child (or a pet) unattended in a parked car for even a few minutes.


The annual number of fatalities due to traffic accidents


Percent of NY crashes caused by distracted driving in 2014


Reported alcohol-related crashes in 2014

Driving Green in New York

New York encourages motorists to go green by offering several green driver incentives. These incentives are in addition to auto insurance discounts and federal incentives.


New York Emissions Test Exemptions

The state exempts emissions testing for electric cars (both onboard diagnostic system and low-enhanced emissions), new vehicles less than 2 years old, and diesel-powered vehicles with a maximum gross weight of more than 8,500 lbs. However, these vehicles must still undergo annual safety inspections.


High Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) Lane Exemption

This program, called the Clean Pass Program, allows qualifying fuel-efficient, low-emission vehicles to bypass heavy road congestion by using the Long Island Expressway HOV lanes. Vehicles eligible for this incentive include those with an EPA fuel economy rating of at least 45 MPG and super ultra-low emissions vehicles. A Clean Pass sticker must be placed on the vehicle. To apply for a sticker, visit the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles website.


Green Pass Discount

Drivers of hybrids may be eligible for a 10% discount on their E-ZPass. To determine eligibility, you must confirm your vehicle is listed and that your tag has a Thruway logo, make a copy of your registration, and then request the Green Discount by sending a letter to the E-ZPass New York Customer Service Center.

In addition to the above incentives, New York State offers several incentives to local fleet owners in the commercial bus and truck sector. This program, called the New York Truck Voucher Incentive Program (NYT-VIP), offers three funds to vendors who sell alternative fuel vehicles and diesel emission control devices. For more information on this program, please visit the NYT-VIP Fact Sheet.

New York Car Insurance FAQ

Is my credit score a factor when obtaining car insurance in New York State?

Poor credit can make it difficult to receive the cheapest car insurance in New York, but each insurer has its own approach to dealing with driver credit problems. Shop around to get the best rates.

Does New York offer a good-driver discount?

New York offers residents a discount on their auto insurance for being a good driver and remaining accident-free. This "Careful Driver" discount can save you a lot of money on your policy, so ask about it before signing your paperwork. Other potential discounts include:

  • Multi-Policy
  • Multi-Car
  • Family Plans
  • Defensive Driving
  • Anti-Theft
  • Green Vehicle Discounts
  • Automatic Seat Belts/Air Bags
  • Anti-Lock Brakes
  • Daytime Running Lamps
  • Good Student
  • Home Ownership
  • Military Discount

Does New York allow the use of digital insurance cards?

Yes! New York drivers are allowed to provide digital proof of insurance coverage. Proof of insurance should be present or immediately accessible at all times to avoid hefty fines.

What happens if my coverage lapses?

If you experience a lapse in insurance coverage in New York State, your registration and/or driver's license can be suspended. If you're caught driving without insurance, you may be ticketed or arrested and your vehicle can be impounded.

What are New York's blood alcohol concentration (BAC) percentage limits under the state's driving under the influence (DUI) laws?

It is against the law to operate a motor vehicle in New York with the following BAC percentages:

  • .08%+ at 21 years or older
  • .04%+ for commercial vehicle drivers
  • .02%+ at under 21 years old

There are different levels of DUI in New York State. For more information about New York's DUI laws, refer to the New York Department of Motor Vehicles Alcohol and Other Drugs web page.

What are the chemical test refusal penalties in New York?

Under New York's "Implied Consent" law, driving a vehicle means you've consented to a blood, urine, or saliva test to measure your BAC. If you refuse to take the test, your driver's license will be suspended and the refusal can be held against you as evidence of guilt when you go to court for alcohol or drug-related charges.

What are the consequences of being convicted of a DUI?

The consequences of being convicted of a DUI in New York are severe and depend on your age, blood alcohol level, and whether you were transporting a child at the time of your offense. Even a single DUI conviction can result in high fees, legal expenses, license suspensions, mandatory installation of an ignition interlock device, and even jail time. Killing or harming another person due to alcohol or drug-related violation can result in thousands of dollars in fines and a maximum jail term of 15 years.

Does New York offer driver improvement courses to reduce my insurance premium?

Yes. New York State offers a Point and Insurance Reduction Program, which includes a Defensive Driving or Accident Prevention Course, to help prevent loss of license and reduce the base rate of your car insurance premiums.

Is there any way I can reduce the cost of my New York car insurance?

Reducing the cost of your New York auto insurance starts with keeping an eye on your credit score, shopping around and comparing insurance rates, and inquiring about your eligibility for all available discounts. Paying upfront, remaining accident-free, and avoiding coverage lapses will also keep your bill under control.

What is uninsured motorist coverage and is it required in New York?

Despite laws requiring all drivers to carry auto insurance, some people still choose to drive without it. As a result, it's important for insured drivers to also carry uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage to recover compensation following an accident with an uninsured driver. New York does not require underinsured motorist coverage, but it is highly recommended. The state does require uninsured motorist coverage.

Compare Car Insurance Rates in New York for Free

Answer a few questions and let Penny find the best rates in your area.