How Much Is Wisconsin Car Insurance?

Ever wonder how much drivers in Wisconsin pay for car insurance? Check out the average price that most people pay and see if you can find a cheaper rate.

Get Quotes in Less Than 3 Minutes

Affordable Car Insurance in Wisconsin

Wisconsin may be known as “America’s Dairyland” and famous for its cheese, but it also deserves recognition for its really low average car insurance premiums! That’s right: The Badger State typically ranks in the bottom two or three states in the nation on lists for lowest auto insurance rates.

While that’s great news for residents, don’t let it stop you from doing what you can to further minimize your monthly payments. For example, a variety of discounts and incentives may be available to you. We’ll go over many of them—and other ways to save—throughout this page.

But the single most effective way to cut your car insurance costs is to thoroughly comparison shop for the lowest quotes from leading Wisconsin carriers. And it just so happens that that’s what we’re here for. Take a couple of minutes to answer a few questions, and SmartFinancial connects you with competing quotes in a carrier-neutral way. It’s incredibly fast and simple, and it’s all available to you for free!

Cheapest Auto Insurance Rates in Wisconsin

Carriers look at multiple variables when determining your insurance rate. Your age, location, driving history, and state requirements are all factors in determining the price you pay. We used our in-house reporting to determine the companies that offer the cheapest car insurance rates in Wisconsin. USAA came in with the lowest rate currently available in Wisconsin at $73.13 per month. Followed by SECURA Insurance at $76.93 per month and State Farm at $81.58 per month.

Lowest Rate


Highest Rate


Average Rate


RankCompanyAvg monthly rate
1 USAA $73.13 / month
2 SECURA Insurance $76.93 / month
3 State Farm $81.58 / month
4 Auto-Owners Insurance Co $91.63 / month
5 West Bend Mutual $96.55 / month
6 American Family $102.56 / month
7 Erie $110.18 / month
8 Rockford Mutual Insurance $112.00 / month
9 Pekin Insurance $117.43 / month
10 Nationwide $134.53 / month
11 Hastings Mutual Insurance Co $137.30 / month
12 Farmers $141.85 / month
13 Western National $152.53 / month
14 Rural Mutual Insurance $155.83 / month
15 Dairyland $159.09 / month
16 State Auto $164.50 / month
17 Auto Club Group $166.89 / month
18 Encompass $168.30 / month
19 Allstate $182.40 / month
20 Acuity $200.27 / month
21 Liberty Mutual $214.42 / month
22 Safeco $228.89 / month
23 Sentry $240.59 / month
24 Metropolitan $291.67 / month
25 Unitrin $326.71 / month

Top 10 Cheapest Cities for Car Insurance

If you are lucky enough to live in one of these cities you are likely paying some of the lowest car insurance rates available in Wisconsin. According to our data, Jefferson comes in at the cheapest at only $69.31 per month. Other cities that made the top 10 list include Two Rivers at $69.64 per month, Grafton at $73.08 per month, and Plymouth at $74.31 per month.

RankCityAvg monthly rate
1 Jefferson, WI$69.31 / month
2 Two Rivers, WI$69.64 / month
3 Grafton, WI$73.08 / month
4 Plymouth, WI$74.31 / month
5 Sturgeon Bay, WI$74.83 / month
6 Manitowoc, WI$75.58 / month
7 Tomahawk, WI$75.93 / month
8 Fort Atkinson, WI$76.10 / month
9 Platteville, WI$77.24 / month
10 Stevens Point, WI$78.09 / month

Top 10 Most Expensive Cities for Car Insurance

These top 10 cities ranked as the most expensive places in Wisconsin for car insurance. Location is a big factor when determining the price you pay for car insurance and these cities came in at the top. Greenfield is the most expensive city in Wisconsin at $174.38 per month. Second and third place goes to West Allis at $150.71 per month and Milwaukee at $129.92 per month.

RankCityAvg monthly rate
1 Greenfield , WI $174.38 / month
2 West Allis , WI $150.71 / month
3 Milwaukee , WI $129.92 / month
4 Fitchburg , WI $111.05 / month
5 Oak Creek , WI $106.93 / month
6 Brookfield , WI $106.83 / month
7 Cudahy , WI $105.23 / month
8 Kenosha , WI $103.11 / month
9 Franklin , WI $100.65 / month
10 Waupaca , WI $100.14 / month

Average Quotes by Top Companies

Rates can vary wildly from company to company. Here is a quick look at a few rates from some of the top car insurance companies in Wisconsin.

Compare Recent Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

SmartFinancial helps thousands of drivers every day find and compare the best car insurance rates available. Here is a list of some recent quotes that we recently found for drivers in Wisconsin.

CompanyMonthly rateVehicle
Foremost Auto $1252016 Dodge Journey
ClearCover $1032016 Dodge Journey
Dairyland $1082016 Dodge Journey
Metlife $1112016 Dodge Journey
Everest $1032024 Honda Civic
ClearCover $692015 Nissan Pathfinder
21st Century $812015 Ford F150
Mercury $592016 Buick Encore
Safeco $722013 Ford Escape
ClearCover $592012 Chevrolet Silverado
Liberty Mutual $1042012 Mazda 5
21st Century $852015 Ram 1500


The statistics listed on this page are from our own in house reporting. We track and record quotes that carriers have provided based on various criteria. The rates and averages shown on this page should only be used as an estimate.

Minimum Car Insurance Coverage in Wisconsin

Every state requires drivers to have a minimum amount of liability coverage. Wisconsin drivers are required to carry liability insurance to pay for damages and injuries inflicted on someone else in an auto accident.


Bodily injury coverage per person

Maximum payment for serious or permanent injury or death to a single person


Bodily injury coverage per accident

Coverage for multiple people injured in a single accident


Property damage per accident

Maximum payment for all damaged property in an accident caused by you

All Wisconsin drivers must have an auto insurance policy providing liability coverage in the minimum amounts of $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 bodily injury per accident, and $10,000 property damage per accident.

The State also mandates uninsured motorist coverage of at least $25,000 bodily injury per person and $50,000 bodily injury per accident. This is a protection against hit-and-run drivers and uninsured drivers who cause an accident.

While minimum coverage squares you with the law and the Wisconsin DMV, it’s not always enough to pay for everything following a serious accident. It’s advisable to buy a policy with higher-than-minimum limits if it’s possible for you. Also, optional insurance add-ons like those discussed below are important for being covered for an array of repairs and services that aren’t included under liability coverage.

Optional Coverage in Wisconsin

  • Auto Loan/Lease (or "gap")
  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Customized Parts and Equipment
  • Emergency Road Service
  • Excess Electronic Equipment
  • Medical Payments
  • Rental Coverage
  • Towing and Labor
  • Travel Expenses
  • Underinsured Motorist

Some exclusions may apply.

Bear in mind that lenders who provide vehicle financing usually require you to take out comprehensive and collision coverage. Don’t overlook this when shopping for a new policy or calculating your monthly insurance and loan costs.

Wisconsin Car Safety

To the points above, traffic accidents are unfortunately part of driving for most motorists sooner or later. Wisconsin has a relatively low crash fatality rate, but crashes are just as common here as most other places in the U.S.

Distracted and impaired driving, speeding, driving too fast for the conditions, failure to yield the right-of-way, and following the vehicle ahead too closely are all common contributors to accidents. Fatalities and serious injuries are far more likely if you’re not wearing your seat belt, so please remember to buckle up!

Car Safety for Wisconsin Kids

Wisconsin has specific child car safety laws designed to keep kids safe, as proper restraint is so important to preventing serious injuries and death in the event of an accident.

Children under 4 years old and 40 pounds must be in an appropriate car seat. Up to 1 year old and 20 pounds, it should be a rear-facing seat; for the remainder of this window, it should be a front-facing car seat. From over 4 years and 40 pounds up to age 8 and 80 pounds or 4′ 9” tall, children must be secured in an appropriate booster seat. After that, kids must use the vehicle’s seat belts.

Assuming there’s an available back seat, children should always ride there. Front passenger seats are only safe if there isn’t an enabled airbag, as deployment can cause serious injury to kids under 13.

Transporting an improperly restrained child passenger under the age of 4 can result in a fine of $175.30. A first-time violation involving a child age 4 to 8 comes with a penalty of $150.10, and fines increase with subsequent infractions.

So far, Wisconsin lawmakers haven’t passed any legislation to address the situation of young kids being left alone in vehicles. Still, parents and other caregivers need to be aware that this is a dangerous practice. Children can hurt themselves playing around without supervision and even set the vehicle in motion if they’re left with the keys. Strangers passing by may pose a threat, as well.

Additionally, temperatures inside a car, truck, van, or SUV can reach dangerous extremes in fairly little time. Hypothermia and hyperthermia are real risks that can cause permanent damage and even death in kids (and pets).


Total number of crash fatalities in 2015


Number of motorcyclist fatalities in 2015


Number of deaths in alcohol-related crashes in 2015

Driving Green in Wisconsin

Wisconsin offers several incentives to those who purchase and operate eco-friendly vehicles. Residents may qualify for other savings, too, such as federal tax breaks, special grants and loans, and more. Keep up with state and federal laws to stay on top of green driver incentives. You don’t want to miss out.


Vehicle Emissions Testing

In Wisconsin, the DOT determines when vehicles must undergo smog and emissions checks, but you’ll always need to undergo testing before registering your vehicle. However, if you drive a motorcycle or moped, an electric-powered vehicle, a non-motorized vehicle, or a diesel-powered vehicle from certain model years, you’re exempt from vehicle emissions testing. Hybrid vehicles do not qualify for this exception because they use both electricity and gasoline.


Green Driver Insurance Discounts

One of the biggest ways to save when going green is through discounts on your auto insurance premium. Some insurers offer discounts as high as 30% for purchasing an eco-friendly car, limiting driving to pleasure only, and keeping up with vehicle maintenance. To determine what discounts are available and how much you can save, speak with your agent.


Alternative Fuel Tax Refunds and Exemptions

A variety of tax refunds and exemptions exist for green drivers in the state of Wisconsin. Residents who use an alternative fuel to power a taxi for the purpose of transporting passengers may qualify for a reimbursement for the amount paid in state fuel tax. Plus, certain taxes, including excise, privilege, license, and occupational taxes, cannot be charged on alternative fuel by any county, town, village, city, or subdivision. Idle reduction weight exemptions and biodiesel fuel use incentives are also available.

Wisconsin Car Insurance FAQ

Is my credit score a factor when obtaining car insurance in Wisconsin?

Carriers licensed in Wisconsin do make it a regular practice to reference consumer credit reports in determining premiums. Many believe that lower credit scores equate to a higher risk of filing claims.

Does Wisconsin offer a good-driver discount?

It’s common practice for car insurance providers to give out good-driver discounts. Each one has its own qualifying criteria, but it’s usually something like 3 years without an accident or a ticket for a moving violation. Ask your agent for details, and about other discounts that may be available to you, such as:

  • Claims-Free
  • Credit Score
  • Anti-Lock Brakes, Air Bags, or Daytime Running Lights
  • Good Student Grades
  • Continued Policy Renewals
  • Accident-Free
  • Anti-Lock Brake
  • Anti-Theft Device
  • Home Ownership
  • Multi-Car
  • Multiple Line
  • Passive Restraint

Does Wisconsin allow the use of digital insurance cards?

It sure does! Don’t worry about digging through the mess in your glove box anymore. Just request official digital proof of coverage from your carrier and show it on your mobile device next time you need it. Of course, it’s a good idea to keep a printed card in your vehicle as a backup anyway, just in case your phone is dead when you get pulled over.

What happens if my coverage lapses?

No matter the reason, driving without coverage in Wisconsin is against the law and subject to up to $500 in fines. You will also be required to promptly obtain a policy to retain your driving privileges.

What are Wisconsin's blood alcohol concentration (BAC) percentage limits under the state's driving under the influence (DUI) laws?

It’s illegal to operate a motor vehicle in Wisconsin with the following BAC percentages:s:

.08%+ at 21 years old or older
.04%+ for commercial vehicle drivers
.02%+ at under 21 years old

In Wisconsin, driving a car under the influence of alcohol or drugs is known as OWI, or Operating While Intoxicated. Although first, second, and third offenses require a BAC of 0.08%, fourth and subsequent offenses require a BAC of only 0.02%. Also, you can be charged and convicted of OWI due to the use of marijuana, cocaine, other illegal drugs, prescription medications, and over-the-counter drugs while driving.

What are the chemical test refusal penalties in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin’s implied consent law means you agreed to take a blood, urine, or blood test to determine your BAC when you acquired a driver’s license. Refusal to submit to a chemical test will result in the immediate revocation of your license for 1 year if this is your first refusal. A second refusal within 10 years of the first results in license revocation for 2 years and a third offense within 10 years triggers a loss of driving privileges for 3 years.

What are the consequences of being convicted of a DUI?

Penalties for OWI range in severity depending on the number and type of offenses. At the very least, you face fines, court costs, suspension of your driver’s license for at least 6 months, and potential jail time. Transporting a minor while intoxicated or causing bodily harm to another person will result in considerably harsher punishments. A BAC of 0.15% results in mandatory participation in a sobriety program.

Find extensive detailed information in this PDF from the Wisconsin Department of Transportation.

Does Wisconsin offer driver improvement courses to reduce my insurance premium?

It’s standard practice at many car insurance companies to give a discount to customers who voluntarily take a qualifying defensive driving course. Inquire about whether this is something you’re eligible for, and which driver improvement courses are approved for this purpose.

Is there any way I can reduce the cost of my Wisconsin car insurance?

Of course, there are! We’ve already addressed a number of discounts and incentives on this page. On top of those, you can pay upfront for a full term of coverage rather than monthly, and choose a higher deductible for a lower premium. In the long run, it definitely pays to get and keep your credit score up, and to do your best to maintain a clean driving record. However, there’s no better way to reduce what you pay than taking just a few minutes with SmartFinancial to comparison shop for the lowest quotes on coverage in Wisconsin when it’s time for a new policy!

What is uninsured motorist coverage and is it required in Wisconsin?

This is an optional coverage in some states, but yes, it’s mandatory in Wisconsin. It provides payments for injuries sustained by you or any of your passengers if you’re in an accident caused by an uninsured driver or one who flees the crash site. All policies in the state must have at least $25,000 bodily injury coverage per person and $50,000 bodily injury coverage per accident.

Compare Car Insurance Rates in Wisconsin for Free

Answer a few questions and let Penny find the best rates in your area.