Don't Get Tricked: 6 Reasons You Need Car Insurance (and Candy) on Halloween

secure Editorial Standards

SmartFinancial Offers Unbiased, Fact-based Information. Our fact-checked articles are intended to educate insurance shoppers so they can make the right buying decisions. Learn More

Candy is great on Halloween but car insurance is even better if you get into an accident. With trick-or-treaters on the streets and partying drunk drivers behind the wheel, your accident exposure goes up on this spooky holiday.

Fortunately, car insurance can provide financial protection for accidents and Halloween mischief, like vandalism and theft. You’ll thank yourself for having the right level of auto insurance coverage if your Halloween is more trick than treat.

Why Do You Need Car Insurance on Halloween?

Your chances of getting into an accident on Halloween increase due to the presence of more pedestrians and drunk drivers. Your car is vulnerable to theft and vandalism on this night of mischief, as well. Full coverage — your state’s insurance requirements plus collision and comprehensive coverage — will protect you in most accidents and from most types of Halloween trickery.

1. Kids and Pedestrians

With more children on the street on Halloween, the chances of getting into an accident with a pedestrian increase. Not all children are supervised and some may wear costumes that obstruct their vision. They may also cross the street thinking it’s clear when there is a car approaching.

Ideally, you should avoid driving at night when visibility is limited. If you can’t avoid it, maintain a lower speed when driving through neighborhoods and be extra vigilant for pedestrians.

Are you covered? If you accidentally strike a pedestrian with your car, liability insurance will cover them for their injuries and property damages. If there was any damage to your car after the accident, collision coverage will pay for your repairs.

2. Drunk Drivers

There were 56 fatal drunk-driving crashes on Halloween in 2020 alone according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. For some people, just one drink is enough to significantly hamper driving capabilities.

Your insurance carrier will pay for accidents caused by your drunk driving but your insurance premiums will likely skyrocket. Beyond higher premiums, you can expect to pay $10,000, on average, in attorney’s fees, fines, court costs, lost time at work and more.

Are you covered? If a drunk driver hits you, they will likely be held liable and their liability coverage should cover their losses. If they are uninsured, the following coverages in your auto policy would cover you:

  • Collision: Pays for your property damages
  • Medical payments/Personal injury protection (Medpay/PIP): Pays for your medical bills if you are injured.
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage: Pays for your property damages and medical expenses if the other driver is uninsured or does not have enough coverage. UM/UIM coverage may not be necessary if you have collision and Medpay/PIP coverage.

Your chances of getting into an accident on Halloween increase due to the presence of more pedestrians and drunk drivers.

3. Car Theft

The number of car thefts spiked during Halloween in four of five years analyzed by the National Insurance Crime Bureau. Halloween is a holiday of pranks, mischief and for some, ingesting substances that lead to reckless behavior. Amidst the Halloween trickery, your car may be the unlikely target of theft.

Are you covered? Comprehensive insurance will cover theft and will pay to replace your car (up to the policy limits) if it’s stolen. Contents inside the car are covered by renters or homeowners insurance.

4. Tricks and Pranks on Vehicles

On Halloween, your car could fall victim to somewhat harmless pranks by your friends or criminal activity with malicious intent. Be on the lookout for:

  • Egging
  • Toilet papering
  • Vandalizing
  • Break-ins
  • Smashing windows
  • Theft
  • Flipping your car
  • Pouring sugar into your gas tank

Are you covered? Comprehensive insurance will cover losses related to any of the above Halloween pranks — that includes a sugar spike in your car’s gasoline levels.

5. Halloween Decorations

Halloween decor displayed in your neighbors’ front yards or roofs may be poorly anchored. A strong gust can easily knock over a Halloween decoration with your car in its fall trajectory, causing damage.

Are you covered? Damages to your vehicle due to another person’s Halloween decor will likely be covered under the comprehensive portion of your auto insurance policy. Alternatively, it may be possible to file a claim against the homeowner with their home insurance provider.

6. Cars With Costumes

For extra festivity, some people put costumes and Halloween accessories on their cars — just be careful the embellishments will not impede driving for yourself or drivers around you. Also, secure the costume well because it may cause scratches or dents to your car or fly off your car entirely and hit a pedestrian or car.

Are you covered? Damages to your car by the car costume may be covered under collision coverage — double-check with your provider. If the costume injures or causes property damage to someone else, your liability insurance will apply.

Ideally, you should avoid driving at night when visibility is limited. If you can’t avoid it, maintain a lower speed.

Find Affordable Full Coverage Car Insurance

Liability coverage is mandated in most states and will cover you if you can be held responsible for another person’s injuries or property damages. Below, we highlight other auto insurance coverages worth having on Halloween.



Example Scenario

Liability (Bodily Injury)

Pays for medical costs if you cause injury to another person

You strike a trick-or-treater with your car

Liability (Property Damage)

Pays when you are liable for another person’s property damages

You strike a mailbox while driving through the neighborhood


Pays for damages to your car, regardless of which driver was at fault

Your car was dented after backing into your gate


Pays for non-collision damages, such as damage from hail, falling objects, vandalism, theft and fire

Your car was stolen while you stayed home watching scary movies

Uninsured/Uninsured Motorist

Covers your injuries and property damages when the other driver has zero or insufficient coverage

A drunk driver crashes into your car but doesn’t have car insurance

Medical Payments

Pays for you and your passengers’ medical costs, regardless of who was at fault

You drive into a tree and injure your hip

Personal Injury Protection (no fault states only)

Pays for you and your passengers’ medical costs, regardless of who was at fault

A speeding driver runs a red light, striking you and causing you a neck injury

The number of car thefts spiked during Halloween in the past four of five years.

Ways To Protect Your Car and Others When Driving On Halloween

The best type of auto insurance claim is one you don’t have to file. On Halloween, practice these driving safety tips to keep the streets safer for everybody.

  • Drive slowly through neighborhoods: Reducing your speed gives you enough time to safely stop when a trick-or-treater darts across the street.
  • Avoid driving during peak treat-or-treating hours: Trick-or-treating typically occurs from sunset to around 9:00 pm. However, stay vigilant because some children will stay out past curfew.
  • Park your car inside a garage or behind a gate: Reducing access to your car can help deter car thieves.
  • Triple-check when pulling in and out of driveways: Small children playing and running can be hard to spot. Check your mirrors and over your shoulder at least three times before pulling in and out of driveways.
  • Turn down your radio volume: Loud music can be distracting and can drown out noises that could signal potential accidents. For example, hearing children laughing should automatically signal you to reduce your speed and increase your vigilance.
  • Avoid eating candy and driving: Unwrapping candy wrappers while driving takes your hands off the wheel and can reduce your reaction time. Save the sweets for when you’re safely parked or at home.
  • Do not let your costume interfere with your driving: Masks can reduce your visibility, long sleeves can interfere with your grasp on the steering wheel and a big wizard’s hat may obstruct your ability to turn your neck. Either take off accessories that impede your driving or arrange for somebody else to drive.
  • Activate your hazard lights when picking up or dropping off: Your hazard lights will alert the driver behind you to be careful because pedestrians are present.

How To File a Halloween Claim

If you get into an accident on Halloween, follow these steps to file an insurance claim with your carrier.

  1. Check for injuries: If anyone is injured, notify the police immediately and refrain from moving the injured party. If everybody is safe, activate your hazard lights and safely pull over to a safe spot.
  2. Exchange information with the involved party: Obtain the contact information of the other person and eyewitnesses. If the accident involved another driver, obtain their car insurance information. If you notified the police, get their name and badge number and ask how to obtain a copy of the police report.
  3. Document the accident: Take pictures of property damages and injuries that you or the other party suffered. Don’t forget to snap photos of where the accident occurred and the road and weather conditions.
  4. Contact your insurance company: Your insurer will walk you through the insurance claims process and instruct how you can upload the documentation gathered in the prior step. If anyone was injured, they may request copies of the medical bills.
  5. Get your car repaired: If you experienced damage to your car, you can complete repairs from an approved repair facility or one of your choosing.
  6. Report the accident to the DMV: Some states require you to report the accident to the DMV if the accident involved significant property damages or any injuries. Double-check with your state DMV.
Find Affordable Full Coverage Car Insurance


Does car insurance cover Halloween vandalism?

Comprehensive insurance, an optional coverage, will cover you for vandalism claims.

Are there car insurance discounts on Halloween?

Halloween car insurance discounts are generally unavailable but this may vary by location. Talk to your insurance agent for more information.

Should you avoid driving on Halloween night?

Refraining from driving on Halloween night is the best way to avoid accidents. If you have to drive, reduce your speed in neighborhoods and remain extra vigilant for children and drunk drivers.

Will my car be covered if Halloween decor damages it?

Damages to your car by Halloween decor are covered if you purchased comprehensive coverage.

Key Takeaways

  • Drivers should be extra careful when driving on Halloween evening due to the presence of trick-or-treaters and drunk drivers.
  • Comprehensive coverage provides coverage for several types of Halloween pranks on vehicles, including theft and vandalism.
  • If you’re the at-fault driver in a Halloween car accident, collision coverage will pay for your car damages.

Cheaper car insurance rates are just as sweet as your favorite candy. SmartFinancial’s free online tool analyzes car insurance companies in your area to match you with the cheapest car insurance policy based on your coverage needs — all in just a few minutes. Just enter your zip code below or call 855.214.2291 to receive your free car insurance quotes.

Get a Free Auto Insurance Quote Online Now.