Which States Have the Cheapest Car Insurance Rates?

secure Editorial Standards

SmartFinancial Offers Unbiased, Fact-based Information. Our fact-checked articles are intended to educate insurance shoppers so they can make the right buying decisions. Learn More

States like Nebraska, Wyoming, Wisconsin, Idaho and Vermont have some of the lowest car insurance rates in the country, with select insurers offering minimum coverage for an average cost of around $330 to $360 less than the national average.[1][2] Numerous factors can cause car insurance premiums to be lower in one state than another including each state’s laws, economic climate and exposure to various kinds of covered losses.

Keep reading to learn more about the states with the cheapest car insurance policies and the steps you can take to lower your premium if you live in one of the more expensive states for auto coverage.

Key Takeaways

  • Nebraska has the lowest average premium for minimum coverage car insurance from any one insurer, as American National only charges $126 per year on average in Nebraska.
  • When taking all insurance companies in each state into account, Wyoming has the lowest average car insurance costs for both minimum coverage and full coverage car insurance, with average premiums of $185 and $972 per year, respectively.
  • Throughout the country, drivers pay $487 per year for minimum coverage and $1,717 per year for full coverage on average.
  • Car insurance prices differ among states because insurers consider numerous location-specific details in the underwriting process such as crash and theft rates, exposure to natural disasters and economic conditions.
  • Some of the steps you may be able to take to save money on auto insurance include shopping around, opting for a higher deductible, switching to a telematics insurance program and asking your insurer about discounts.

Why Do Car Insurance Rates Vary From State to State?

Auto insurance rates vary from state to state because each state sets its own car insurance requirements, meaning the cost of minimum coverage in your state depends on what types of coverage the government requires you to buy and how high the minimum coverage limits are. You can also expect car insurance companies to take other state-specific or ZIP-code-specific factors into account when underwriting your policy such as regional weather patterns and the cost of medical treatments and property repairs in your area.

Additionally, the rates of uninsured drivers, car accidents and crimes in your state can influence how much you have to pay for auto insurance since they may indicate how likely you are to file a car insurance claim. Issues like these may be more prevalent in regions with a higher population density, so car insurance coverage is often more expensive in urban areas than in rural areas.[3]

Cheapest Car Insurance Rates by State

See the below table for an overview of the cheapest car insurance companies that offer the lowest median annual premiums for minimum coverage car insurance in each state, ordered from cheapest to most expensive.[1]

State/District

Median Annual Premium

Cheapest Insurer

Nebraska

$126

American National

Wyoming

$132

American National

Wisconsin

$147

Integrity

Idaho

$148

American National

Vermont

$159

Union Mutual

Colorado

$165

American National

Iowa

$175

GEICO

Massachusetts

$176

Vermont Mutual

Montana

$179

State Farm

South Carolina

$190

American National

New Hampshire

$193

The Hanover

North Dakota

$199

Nodak

Ohio

$200

Central Insurance

South Dakota

$202

North Star

Arkansas

$204

The Hanover

Michigan

$204

Wolverine Mutual

Kentucky

$211

Kentucky Farm Bureau

Washington

$230

Pemco

Pennsylvania

$231

Auto-Owners

Oklahoma

$237

GEICO

California

$239

GEICO

Alabama

$241

Cincinnati Insurance

Arizona

$246

Noblr

Tennessee

$260

Tennessee Farm Bureau

Maine

$262

Vermont Mutual

Hawaii

$270

GEICO

Kansas

$272

GEICO

New Mexico

$278

Progressive

Utah

$279

QBE

Illinois

$283

GEICO

Alaska

$287

Allstate

Mississippi

$295

Direct Auto

Minnesota

$297

Westfield

Indiana

$306

Hastings Mutual

Florida

$307

GEICO

Virginia

$309

Virginia Farm Bureau

Missouri

$310

GEICO

Oregon

$318

California Casualty

District of Columbia

$319

Chubb

West Virginia

$324

Westfield

Georgia

$326

Central Insurance

New Jersey

$342

State Farm

Maryland

$355

GEICO

New York

$359

NYCM

Nevada

$376

GEICO

Texas

$376

State Farm

North Carolina

$383

Progressive

Delaware

$420

Travelers

Louisiana

$440

GEICO

Connecticut

$453

Travelers

Rhode Island

$524

Amica

States With Cheapest Car Insurance on Average

In the following states, the statewide average car insurance cost for minimum coverage across all insurance carriers is more than $100 lower than the national average cost of $487 per year, making them some of the cheapest states for car insurance across the board:[2]

State

Average Annual Minimum Coverage Premium

Wyoming

$185

Iowa

$260

South Dakota

$280

Vermont

$310

Idaho

$320

Alaska

$322

Nebraska

$329

Ohio

$335

North Dakota

$367

Pennsylvania

$367

Wisconsin

$367

New Hampshire

$368

Meanwhile, the following states have an average premium for full coverage car insurance that is more than $300 lower than the nationwide average of $1,717 per year:[2]

State

Average Annual Full Coverage Premium

Wyoming

$972

Vermont

$1,082

New Hampshire

$1,119

Idaho

$1,162

Ohio

$1,209

Maine

$1,234

Massachusetts

$1,296

Oregon

$1,346

Iowa

$1,381

Unsurprisingly, Wyoming stands out as the state with the cheapest car insurance rates for both minimum coverage and full coverage. Factors that contribute to Wyoming’s low car insurance prices include the fact that it has the smallest population of any state and that its state government only requires drivers to carry liability coverage.[4][5]

How Do I Keep My Car Insurance Rates Low Where I Live?

Regardless of what state you live in, the best way to find low car insurance rates is by comparing quotes from around three to five different insurance companies to see which insurer can offer the best price for the coverage you need. You can click here to start shopping around for auto insurance through SmartFinancial at no cost.

Another way you could potentially save money is by opting into a telematics or pay-per-mile car insurance program, which can lead to lower premiums if you consistently practice safe driving habits or rarely drive at all. In addition, raising your deductible will typically lower your car insurance rate since your insurance provider won’t have to pay as much money whenever you file a claim.

Of course, you should also look into car insurance discounts that your insurance company offers and see if you are already eligible or could easily qualify for any of them. Examples of common discounts include the following:

  • Safe driving: As a general rule, good drivers pay less for auto insurance since they cost their insurance providers less money. If you go several years without filing any claims, getting into any car accidents or committing any traffic violations, your insurance rates may go down.
  • Good student: Many insurers offer discounted rates on policies that cover good students who maintain a high grade point average (GPA). Typically, you can qualify if you or your child has a GPA of 3.0 or better.
  • Anti-theft: It may be beneficial to install an anti-theft device such as a kill switch, car alarm or GPS tracker into your vehicle. Since these devices can lower the odds that you will need to file a claim related to theft, your insurance company may give you a discount on your insurance policy if you install one or more.
  • Bundling: If your car insurance company also sells other insurance products like homeowners insurance or renters insurance, you can likely secure a bundling discount by purchasing multiple policies from the same carrier.
  • Multi-car: Assuming your family owns multiple vehicles, one of the simplest ways to earn discounted insurance premiums is to add all of the drivers in your household and all of their cars to the same policy. Keep in mind that your insurer may limit the number of cars it will cover to four or five per policy.[6]

common car insurance discounts

Shop Around for a Cheaper Auto Insurance Policy!

FAQs

Which states have the most expensive car insurance?

The states with the highest average car insurance rates for full coverage are Florida, Louisiana, Texas, Rhode Island and Kentucky. In all five states, drivers have to pay over $670 more for coverage than the average driver across the country.[2]

Will my car insurance rates change if I move to another state?

Your car insurance rates will most likely change if you move to another state because your premiums depend heavily on multiple factors that are linked to your ZIP code.

Why is car insurance more expensive in some states?

Car insurance may be more expensive in one state than another due to differences in state laws, medical and property repair expenses, weather patterns and rates of uninsured drivers, car accidents and crimes.

Sources

  1. NerdWallet. “Don’t Overpay: Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in 2024.” Accessed June 24, 2024.
  2. NerdWallet. “Average Cost of Car Insurance.” Accessed June 24, 2024.
  3. Insurance Information Institute. “What Determines the Price of an Auto Insurance Policy?” Accessed June 24, 2024.
  4. World Population Review. “US States - Ranked by Population 2024.” Accessed June 24, 2024.
  5. Wyoming Department of Transportation. “Frequently Asked Questions.” Accessed June 24, 2024.
  6. Experian. “How Many Cars Can You Insure on One Policy?” Accessed June 24, 2024.

Get a Free Auto Insurance Quote Online Now.